If you put $100,000 in XEQT, BlackRock’s target puts $25,000 in Canadian stocks. Invest the same $100,000 at the country weights of ZALL’s benchmark and roughly $3,060 goes to Canada. Both are global stock portfolios you can buy with one ticker. So what is that extra $22,000 in Canada doing for you?
If I were starting from scratch and wanted one ETF in Canadian dollars for the stock portion of my portfolio, I’d start with ZALL. If I already owned XEQT and was happy with roughly a quarter in Canada, I’d keep it.
XEQT has become the default reference point for a one-fund stock portfolio in Canada. It launched in 2019 and had nearly $24 billion in assets as of November 17, 2026. That’s a lot of money behind a simple idea. Buy one fund and let it keep the regional weights in place for you.
If you wanted that same simplicity with each country weighted by its share of the global market, the usual answer was Vanguard’s Total World Stock ETF (VT). It trades in U.S. dollars on a U.S. exchange. When BMO announced ZALL on November 13, what caught my attention was that you could get that approach to country weights in one TSX-listed fund, in Canadian dollars. The two benchmarks do differ in the sizes of companies they include.
Some of the investors in the launch thread wondered why it took this long. You could already pair XAW, which owns global stocks outside Canada, with a Canadian index fund and match Canada’s global weight yourself. ZALL does that in one fund, and Canada’s share moves with the market. The BMO ETF team said on Reddit that an earlier discussion about this very gap sparked the idea for ZALL.
What does it mean to own the market?
Imagine a stock market with only two companies. One has $80 million in shares available to investors and the other has $20 million. If you want to own the same fraction of each company’s available shares, you put 80% of your money into the first company and 20% into the second. That’s market-cap weighting. Apply that idea across countries and each country gets a share based on the combined value of its stocks in the index.
The appeal is that I can start with the market’s mix of stocks without having to decide how big any one company or country ought to be. In the textbook model Fama and French describe, investors share the same portfolio of risky assets and choose how much overall risk to take. A global equity index is a practical way to apply that idea to the listed stocks it covers.
ZALL tracks the MSCI All Country World Index, and Canada gets whatever weight it has in that index. XEQT instead aims to keep a quarter of its portfolio in Canadian stocks. Giving your own market more weight than it gets in a global benchmark is what people mean by home bias.
| Exposure or cost | XEQT | ZALL |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | 25% target | 3.06% in the index |
| United States | 45% target | 64.63% in the index |
| How weights are set | Rebalances to regional targets | Follows global market weights |
| Stock sizes | Includes small caps through underlying funds | Large and mid caps in the benchmark |
| Management fee | 0.17% | 0.18% |
| Reported MER | 0.19% | Unavailable at launch |
ZALL’s country figures are the MSCI ACWI weights as of October 30, 2026. Fees are from BlackRock’s XEQT fund page and BMO’s ZALL ETF Facts.
To see what the Canada weight alone does, imagine two portfolios with the same Canadian and foreign stock baskets. If Canadian stocks beat the foreign basket by 10 percentage points in Canadian dollars, the 25% Canada portfolio beats the 3.06% version by about 2.2 percentage points for that period. Flip the result and the gap goes the other way. That’s just the difference in weights multiplied by the difference in returns.
How much do small caps matter?
The funds also differ in which sizes of companies they cover. ZALL’s benchmark covers large and mid caps, which make up about 85% of the investable global stock market by value. MSCI has a broader version called ACWI IMI that also covers small caps. One of XEQT’s underlying funds, XEF, tracks the MSCI EAFE IMI Index, which includes small caps in developed markets outside the U.S. and Canada.
What would those smaller companies change? MSCI’s small-cap index holds thousands of names, but the segment represents only about 14% of the stock market’s investable value under MSCI’s definition. Say small caps make up 14% of an all-cap portfolio and beat large and mid caps by 5 percentage points over a year. That adds about 0.7 percentage points to your return compared with holding just the large and mid caps. If small caps lag by five points, it costs you about the same. That’s enough to care about, especially if it persists for years. For me, it’s a reason to prefer an all-cap fund when it’s just as easy to own.
I’d own that extra slice mainly to spread my money across more businesses. Cliff Asness and co-authors found a stronger small-cap premium after accounting for differences in company quality. A market-weighted all-cap fund buys the small companies alongside the large ones at their market weights. I’d value the extra coverage and let future returns settle the rest.
Why give Canada a bigger share?
In my 2023 video on XEQT and VEQT, one of the more interesting explanations came from BlackRock itself. On Rational Reminder episode 31, Steven Leong said Canadians were accustomed to holding more Canadian stocks, and BlackRock wanted its new portfolios to fit what people already held while nudging them toward more global exposure. He was talking about XBAL and XGRO. It helps explain the thinking behind the lineup. There’s something to the idea that people can stick with a fund more easily when they recognize what’s in it. That tells us something about the investor, and very little about what those companies will earn.
On Canadian Couch Potato episode 20, Dan Bortolotti asked Todd Schlanger, one of the architects of Vanguard’s Canadian allocation ETFs, why Vanguard overweighted Canada and how it handled currency. There are practical reasons for owning more at home. The Canadian dividend tax credit applies in taxable accounts. A stronger Canadian dollar can take a bite out of the Canadian-dollar return on unhedged foreign stocks. A weaker dollar can help. Buying a fund in Canadian dollars leaves the underlying currency exposure in place unless the fund hedges it.
Canadian dividends can still have an edge inside a TFSA or RRSP. Say a Canadian company pays $100 in dividends into your TFSA. You keep all $100. If a U.S. company pays the same amount, you typically keep $85 after U.S. withholding tax. With Canadian-listed funds like XEQT and ZALL, tax can come out of foreign dividends inside the fund before any cash reaches your account.
U.S. withholding generally applies to VT’s dividends in a TFSA too. An RRSP holding VT or a U.S. stock directly generally avoids U.S. withholding on the dividends it receives. Other countries can still withhold tax on dividends before they reach VT. Any withholding that applies in either account stays a cost to you.
In Vanguard’s historical analysis, a mix of about 30% Canada and 70% foreign stocks had the lowest volatility from 1999 through May 2023. Vanguard’s later model of expected volatility also supports 30% under its assumptions. That can happen even when Canadian stocks are more volatile on their own. What matters is how much the two baskets move together. Fidelity’s comparison of sector weights points to one reason they might behave differently. Canada has more of its market in financials, energy and materials and less in technology. Think of what a jump in oil prices might do for a Canadian oil producer versus a big U.S. tech company. If the two baskets respond differently often enough, adding some Canada can smooth out the whole portfolio.
Currency can matter too. In several big stock selloffs, a falling Canadian dollar softened the loss on unhedged foreign stocks. When the Canadian dollar falls, the foreign investments you still hold are worth more when you convert them back to Canadian dollars, all else equal. That’s one reason I’d want to keep plenty invested abroad.
Ben Felix ran a separate check using Canadian-dollar real returns from 1900 through 2022. Around 30–40% Canada gave him the highest Sharpe ratio, which measures how much return you earned above a risk-free investment per unit of volatility. That result depends on the returns as well as how bumpy the ride was, and as Felix pointed out, Canada was one of the stronger markets in that history.
I think XEQT’s 25% Canada makes sense if you want less riding on the biggest U.S. companies and you’re comfortable owning more Canadian banks and resource companies. I’d make that trade for the chance of a smoother ride in Canadian dollars. If the extra Canada also earns me a higher return, I’d call that a bonus.
Should you put a limit on any one country?
On October 30, Apple was 5.02% of the MSCI All Country World Index. All of Canada was 3.06%. Add Nvidia and Microsoft and those three companies alone made up about 13.3% of an index with more than 2,400 stocks. The U.S. as a whole was 64.63%.
If investors bid up U.S. companies relative to the rest of the world, the U.S. automatically gets a bigger share of a market-weighted fund. They might expect those companies to earn more or be willing to pay more for every dollar of profit. I like that I can buy the market without having to decide what the U.S. deserves to weigh. The trade-off is that a long stretch of weak U.S. returns can do a lot more damage when almost two-thirds of my stocks are there.
What happened to Japan?
Japan once made up about 44% of the MSCI World Index, which covers developed markets. In the late 1980s, low interest rates and a surge in bank lending pushed up land and stock prices. Bank of Japan researchers traced part of the boom to an important link. As land became more valuable, businesses could use it to borrow more. That made it easier to finance more buying at higher prices.
The Bank of Japan started raising rates in 1989. Stocks fell in 1990, then land prices fell too. A property that had been good collateral at the top could now be worth less than the loan it backed. Banks were left with bad loans, and it took years to clean up the banking system. The Nikkei 225 finally passed its 1989 closing high in February 2024. That’s the price index in yen, before dividends or the effect of converting to Canadian dollars.
Japan’s weight shrank as its market lagged. A global fund would have adjusted automatically, while anyone who owned it at the peak would still have been exposed to the decline. That’s the part I think about with the U.S. today. Market weights adapt as leadership changes. You still own the big market when the trouble starts.
What do you give up for one fund?
There are ways to give the biggest country less room. MSCI tested weighting countries by the size of their economies. In its developed-markets example, that cut the U.S. share from over 70% to under 50% and reduced exposure to the biggest stocks as well.
Say I wanted to cap the U.S. at 55%. At the October weights, that would free up about $10 out of every $100 to put elsewhere. If I spread it across the rest of the world in proportion to existing market weights, Canada would go from about 3% to about 4%. That’s a very different portfolio from XEQT with its 25% Canada target. Both give the U.S. less weight. One spreads the extra money across many countries, and the other puts a much larger share into Canadian banks and resource companies.
Would 45% outside the U.S. be enough? For the stock part of my portfolio, yes, if it’s spread across developed and emerging markets. For a point of reference, Vanguard’s guide for U.S. investors suggests about 40% of stocks outside the U.S. At 55/45, the U.S. would still have the biggest influence on my returns, but almost half the portfolio would have a chance to do something different.
Say U.S. stocks fell 30% while the rest of the world was flat, with both returns measured in Canadian dollars. The 55/45 mix would lose 16.5%. At ZALL’s October benchmark weights, the loss would be about 19.4%. That’s a meaningful difference if you’re especially concerned about a U.S. slump. It also shows why I’d be comfortable with ZALL. Its roughly 35% outside the U.S. already provides a fair bit of diversification, and going to 45% would soften this particular hit by about three percentage points.
To build that 55% split myself, I could use a U.S. fund and a broad fund for the rest of the world. I’d have to keep track of the split and rebalance when it drifts. With one ETF, I’m letting the fund’s rules make that decision. ZALL follows global market weights. XEQT gives me a lower U.S. target of 45% and rebalances for me, as long as I’m also happy with its 25% Canada target.
For my starting point, I’d take ZALL’s bigger U.S. weight for the simplicity of one Canadian-dollar fund I can leave alone. If I wanted a specific limit badly enough to manage the split myself, I’d pick one I could stick with even when the U.S. kept outperforming. The 55% is just an example.
How much do you already depend on Canada?
Suppose you work for a Canadian bank. A bad stretch for the industry could hit your bonus or your job at the same time it hits a portfolio heavy in Canadian banks. Baxter and Jermann made this point in an older paper. Future earnings from work are part of your wealth, and to the extent those earnings move with domestic stocks, buying more of those same stocks compounds a risk you already have. A paycheque in Canadian dollars tells you the currency you’re paid in. I’d ask what could actually cut your income. Someone who earns commissions selling Canadian homes is more exposed to a local housing slump than someone on a steady salary whose employer sells mostly abroad.
Owning companies in other countries also gets you something that owning more Canadian companies across different industries can’t fully replace. Attig and co-authors looked at stocks across 48 markets from 1995 to 2021. In their study, spreading stocks across countries reduced risk more effectively than spreading them across industries. Differences in market, political and inflation risks helped explain the benefit. Gossé and Jehle found a similar reason to look beyond borders in a 2024 study of European stock portfolios. Several countries could have improved their risk-adjusted results with more cross-border investment. Those studies make a case for taking country risk seriously. They leave open how much Canada belongs in an already global portfolio.
So why did Aizhan Anarkulova, Scott Cederburg and Michael O’Doherty’s August 2026 working paper land near one-third domestic stocks and two-thirds international? In an interview about an earlier version, Cederburg offered one explanation. Say you own US$100 of foreign stocks. If the Canadian dollar strengthens and US$1 goes from C$1.40 to C$1.25, those stocks go from C$140 to C$125 even if their U.S.-dollar price stays put. In the authors’ historical data, home stocks tended to beat foreign stocks over long stretches when the home currency strengthened. In those stretches, owning some stocks at home helped offset the hit from converting foreign returns back to your own currency.
Now go back to the Canadian bank employee. If the same downturn can cut your bonus and knock down your portfolio, there’s a cost to owning more Canadian stocks. In the version Cederburg discussed on Rational Reminder, the model put 33% in domestic stocks when lasting changes in earnings moved independently of the home stock market. When the researchers made earnings and domestic stock returns move together more strongly, with a correlation of 0.5, the model cut the domestic share to 18% and put the difference abroad. Those figures come from a model using data from developed markets. For a Canadian deciding how much to own at home, I’d ask whether a bad year for Canadian stocks is also likely to be a bad year for their pay.
When will you need the money?
If it’s a down payment due in two years, I’d keep that money in a savings account or a GIC that matures in time. All three ETFs are 100% stocks and can be down when you need to sell. The same issue comes up when you’re starting to live off your portfolio. As I showed in the retirement example, selling to cover expenses in a bad market can leave you with less money in the portfolio when stocks recover.
If the money can stay invested for decades and you can hold through a bad market, I’d worry less about which ETF looks a little smoother from year to year. If a big drop would make you sell, I’d decide how much of the portfolio belongs in stocks before worrying about how much of those stocks should be Canadian.
Does ZALL’s size matter?
Yes. XEQT gets the edge on trading history. BlackRock reported $23.4 billion in net assets as of November 19, 2026. Its ETF Facts shows about 1.9 million units traded per day and a 0.03% average bid-ask spread over the year ended April 30, 2026. ZALL’s launch ETF Facts had no comparable trading history. I’d check ZALL’s quotes before placing an order.
Volume tells you how many units changed hands. To see what it might cost to trade now, I’d look at the bid (what someone will pay for my units), the ask (what I can buy them for), and how many units are available at those prices. For example, at a $29.97 bid and a $30.03 ask, buying about $10,000 at the ask costs roughly $10 more than buying at the $30 midpoint, assuming the order fits at that price. ETF dealers can also create units using the underlying holdings, so the day’s trading volume gives you only part of the picture.
Fund size matters for a different reason. If a small fund stays small, the provider might decide to close it. In BMO’s June 2026 closures, investors received the final net asset value of their units. You’d still have to reinvest the proceeds, and in a taxable account the sale can trigger a gain or loss.
For a regular buy-and-hold purchase, I’d still lean ZALL if I wanted its country weights and could get a reasonable quote. I’d use a limit order if I wanted to set the most I’d pay. For a big trade or if the spread stayed wide, I’d give XEQT’s trading history more weight.
Which ETF would I buy?
Starting from scratch, I’d pick ZALL for the stock portion of my portfolio. If I want one fund in Canadian dollars, I’d start by letting the global market set each country’s weight. That puts me at about 3% Canada and roughly two-thirds U.S. today. I’d happily own small caps too. For this choice, I care more about how the country weights are set than about covering the last slice of the market. I’d lean that way even more if a Canadian downturn could already hurt my pay or savings. Maybe I run a business that depends on Canadian customers, get part of my pay in shares of a Canadian bank, or already hold a lot of Canadian stocks in another account.
If I already owned XEQT, I’d keep it if I was happy with 25% in Canada. I’d also choose XEQT from scratch if I specifically wanted more Canadian banks and resource companies in place of some of the biggest U.S. stocks. Both funds are reasonable long-term holdings. I’d switch only if I wanted the new mix enough to stick with it when the other fund is ahead.
I’d choose VT if I wanted global market weights with small caps and could buy it without paying much to convert to U.S. dollars. Holding it directly in an RRSP also gives it the U.S. dividend withholding advantage discussed above.